Taking Ethical Responsibility for Our Investments

Most of us like to think of ourselves as ethical people. We make conscious choices every day about the products we buy, the companies we support, how we show up for our families, our communities, and the world around us. In fact, research consistently shows that Americans overwhelmingly view themselves as moral individuals. One survey found that 92% of Americans are satisfied with their moral character. ^{1 Google Search "Do people from the US consider themselves ethical?"}

Ultimately, ethics matter to us. And yet, when it comes to our investments, many of us unknowingly set those ethics aside. More than half of U.S. citizens have investments through 401(k)s, IRAs, brokerage accounts, or apps like Robinhood and Acorns. Despite this, the financial services industry has largely succeeded in convincing people that their “ethical” investment options are already taken care of. The rise of ESG portfolios, (Environmental, Social, and Governance funds) has given investors a comforting sense that their money is aligned with their values. ^{2 Google Search "Do more than half of US people have investments?" in the world.}

But when you look under the hood, a very different story emerges.

‍

The Illusion of Ethical Investing

ESG portfolios are often marketed as a values-aligned choice. You select the “ethical option,” get a mental pat on the head, and move on. As far as we understand it, these portfolios typically screen out only a small handful of the worst offenders while leaving the core of the portfolio largely unchanged.

In practice, we believe the shift from a conventional portfolio to an ESG portfolio is often minimal. So minimal that it borders on greenwashing. It is our understanding that companies like McDonald’s, Walmart, Chevron, Halliburton, Rio Tinto, Coca-Cola, ExxonMobil, and major weapons manufacturers routinely remain in ESG portfolios offered by some of the largest financial firms.

These are companies deeply entangled in fossil fuel extraction, deforestation, public health crises, labor controversies, weapons production, and Indigenous rights violations. Many investors have no idea they are still supporting these industries, because no one has bothered to tell them.

‍

Why Investments Matter More Than Consumption

Here’s a crucial point that rarely gets discussed: the impact of your investments often outweighs the impact of your personal consumption.

If you add up all the money an average person spends each year on products and services, it is typically only about half of what their invested dollars are doing in the world. Investments don’t just reflect the economy…they actively shape it. ^{3 Google Search "How much money do US people have in investments vs. how much do we spend every year?"}

If we look around and wonder why we see widespread poor health, fast food on every corner, strip malls, strip mining, deforestation, Indigenous land violations, toxic air and water, and a booming weapons industry, we have to acknowledge the role investments play. These outcomes are not accidental. They are funded. And they are funded, in large part, by ordinary people through retirement accounts and “ethical” portfolios that don’t actually live up to their name.

‍

A Closer Look at ESG in Practice

Using third-party tools like YourStake, it’s possible to analyze the real-world impacts of ESG portfolios offered by firms like BlackRock, (the largest investment product provider in the world.) These portfolios are widely available through Fidelity, Acorns, Robinhood, and countless advisors.

Despite the ESG label, these portfolios often include:

• Fossil fuel giants such as ExxonMobil, ConocoPhillips, and Phillips 66
• Weapons manufacturers with extensive involvement in global conflict
• Fast food and beverage companies that contribute to public health crises
• Industrial agriculture firms linked to factory farming and deforestation
• Mining companies such as Rio Tinto, associated with Indigenous rights violations
• Pharmaceutical companies involved in the production of opioid medications

These inclusions aren’t edge cases. They are central holdings.

For example, Rio Tinto has faced global backlash for destroying sacred Indigenous sites, leading to the resignation of its CEO and other executives. Hormel Foods and International Paper have been linked to deforestation. Weapons manufacturers remain embedded throughout ESG portfolios. Yet investors are rarely informed that their retirement savings are supporting these activities. ^{4 Google Search "Does Rio Tinto have any controversy with indigenous rights violations?")}

‍

The Scale of the Impact

Consider someone approaching retirement with $1 million in a 401(k). That money is actively deployed in the global economy every day. Its impact can be five to ten times greater than the combined effect of personal lifestyle choices, what you eat, what you buy, or how you commute.

If we care about climate change, animal welfare, public health, labor rights, Indigenous sovereignty, or peace, it is impossible to ignore the role our investments play. ^{5 Google Search "How much more impact on the world will my million dollars in retirement investments have than my own annual personal consumption habits?"}

‍

‍

There Are Better Options

This is not a call for despair. It is a call for accountability.

There are financial advisors and investment firms that take responsibility for the portfolios they recommend, research individual companies, and construct portfolios designed to align with clients’ values. Approaches such as values-based investing and custom direct indexing allow investors to exclude industries and companies they fundamentally disagree with, without abandoning long-term financial discipline.

These strategies require more intention and transparency than off-the-shelf ESG funds. But they exist, and they offer a meaningful alternative for investors who want their money to reflect their ethics.

‍

The Most Powerful Ethical Action We Can Take

Many of us protest, boycott, sign petitions, build community gardens, and try to live consciously. All of that matters. But the lowest-hanging fruit…the single most impactful ethical shift we can make as a culture…is to look honestly at our investments.

Right now, this is one of humanity’s biggest blind spots. If we shine a light on it and demand better, from our advisors, from financial institutions, and from ourselves, we can redirect capital toward a healthier, more just, and more livable future.

‍

Align Your Investments With Your Values

If you care about ethics, sustainability, and the future of our shared world, your investments deserve the same level of attention as the choices you make in your daily life. ESG labels alone are not enough, and as you’ve seen, they often fail to reflect what most people truly want to support.

At Holistic Finance, we specialize in values-based investing, ethical investment portfolios, and custom direct indexing designed to help investors align their money with what matters most, without sacrificing financial rigor or long-term performance.

Look under the hood of your current investments. Ask better questions of your advisor or retirement plan provider. Explore alternatives beyond traditional ESG funds

If you’re ready to take ethical responsibility for your investments, we invite you to schedule a custom values-based investment consultation with Holistic Finance. We’ll help you understand what your money is really supporting, and what other options may be available to you.

Your money is powerful. Make sure it reflects your values.

‍

Disclosures

Advisory services are offered through Holistic Finance LLC an SEC Investment Advisor. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. References to specific financial institutions are for example purposes only and do not constitute endorsements or recommendations.

Sources

Yourstake.org
Google Search "Do people from the US consider themselves ethical?"
Google Search: "Does Rio Tinto have any controversy with indigenous rights violations?"
Google Search: "Do more than half of US people have investments?"
Google Search: "How much money do US people have in investments vs. how much do we spend every year?"
Google Search: "How much more impact on the world will my million dollars in retirement investments"

‍